Underwood speculating on a particular singer winning or not is fair game given her role as an Idol judge. Seacrest, however, isn’t put in the position of critiquing the crooners.

Ryan Seacrest and Jamal Roberts (right) on the Season 23 finale of "American Idol." "American Idol" winner Jamal Roberts is addressing the discourse surrounding his relationship with judge Carrie ...

FEATURED Listen to Dave & Molly ‘American Idol’ Finale: Carrie Underwood & Ryan Seacrest on Her Winner Prediction Just Like Simon Cowell’s Michael Maloney, TV Insider 59 mins ago ...

A beloved American Idol runner-up has a shocking past with the show, which most viewers probably didn't know about when they ...

A beloved and popular American Idol superstar has parted ways with their longtime love, leaving their fans feeling sad about ...