Stradman’s pizza turned out to leave a much better impression with Portnoy. Portnoy seemed surprised at first learning that a car YouTuber owned the pizza place. But he appreciated the quality. “This?

The Barstool boss had a bit more praise for Stradman, however. “This? Pretty good! Yeah, this is pretty good.” That all-important final score? A 7.7/7.8. “This is good. So, the car guy ...

Barstool Sports founder and internet pizza authority Dave Portnoy handed out one of his highest-ever scores, with a 9.2 score for a slice of pizza, to a little-known newcomer in Manhattan called ...